Friday
March 24, 2006
SGN.org
Volume 34
Issue 12
 
search only SGN online
Wednesday, Sep 23, 2020

 

 



Blogger fights Exodus over parody of "ex-Gay" group
Blogger fights Exodus over parody of "ex-Gay" group
"It's troubling that an organization as big as Exodus would go to such great lengths to silence its critics," said Justin Watt of Justinsomnia.org

Citing First Amendment protection for parodies, the American Civil Liberties Union today came to the defense of a California man who received a cease-and-desist letter after posting a parody of a billboard advertisement for so-called "reparative therapy" on his website.

"The moment I saw the billboards last September, I was deeply offended. The inspiration for the parody I created came to me instantly. How would straight people feel if their very being, their sense of self was being so overtly disparaged?" said Justin Watt, a blogger from Santa Rosa, California. "Their response was to try to intimidate me into taking the image down. It's troubling that an organization as big as Exodus would go to such great lengths to silence its critics."

The billboard, sponsored by "ex-Gay" ministry Exodus International, read, "Gay? Unhappy? www.exodus.to." After seeing a photo of the billboards online, Watt posted an altered version reading, "Straight? Unhappy? www.Gay.com" on his website, Justinsomnia.org. Liberty Counsel, an anti-Gay legal group representing Exodus, sent Watt a cease-and-desist letter earlier this month claiming the parody violated Exodus's intellectual property rights and threatening legal action if the parodies were not removed. In a response sent today to Liberty Counsel, the ACLU's cooperating attorney, Laurence Pulgram of Fenwick & West, LLP, called upon Exodus to drop its attempts to censor Watt, pointing to case law holding parodies to be Constitutionally protected speech.

"Parodies like Justin's are protected by the First Amendment as a form of political commentary. His point was to make a comment on a very important issue he has strongly held beliefs about: that Exodus's tactics are wrong, that there's nothing wrong with being Gay, and that being Gay doesn't make you unhappy," said Ann Brick, a staff attorney with the ACLU of Northern California. "Just as a group like Exodus has a Constitutionally protected right to say whatever it wants to about Gay people, even when that view has been roundly condemned by every major psychological and medical organization, Justin has a right to use parody to voice his opposition."

The American Psychiatric Association, the American Psychological Association, the American Medical Association and other mainstream mental health and medical groups have denounced reparative therapy, stating that there is no evidence that reparative therapy is successful and that the practice may in fact be harmful to those who undergo it.

"Justin's use of Exodus's own image to criticize its message is exactly the sort of speech the Constitution protects," said Pulgram, who heads the copyright litigation group at Fenwick & West. "The law protects people like Justin from groups like Exodus that try to use copyright as a method of bullying their critics into abandoning their First Amendment right to express their opinions through parody."

Watt is represented by Brick, Pulgram, and Tamara Lange of the ACLU's Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender Project.

Additional information about the case, including an image of Watt's billboard parody, the ACLU letter responding to Liberty Counsel's cease and desist letter, and statements from mainstream mental health and medical organizations about reparative therapy, is available at: www.aclu.org/caseprofiles



A ACLU press release

International Readers
We want to learn about you and have you tell us about Gay Life where you live.
Please click here



Seattle Gay Blog It's new!
A blog created
by the SGN staff
so you can be heard



"A TRUE GEM " "GRADE A"
- The Seattle PI

Mrs. Palfrey Home

Bits and Bytes


Like a great, inexpensive
WEBSITE
for your business?

email us for more information
DigitalTeamWorks


bringing you the
SGN - online, every week



2nd Annual WA State
Gayaight Alliance Network Banquet

05.19.06

IKEA
PERFORMING ARTS CENTER

 

at The Center

The Red Series

by
ABDEL




Friday, March 24
Doors at 6:00 p.m.
Seattle LGBT Community Center
a benefit for Dunshee House and the Seattle LGBT Community Center

working for the freedom to
marry since 1995


copyright Seattle Gay News - DigitalTeamWorks 2006